Capital One Auto Says ‘Forever Loans’ Are Not the Crisis Critics Fear

CNBC reported Saturday that Capital One Auto’s top executive is not alarmed by rising vehicle prices or the spread of extended loan terms sometimes called “forever loans.” The remarks come as consumer auto debt draws growing scrutiny across the industry.

Capital One Auto Sees Stability Despite Sticker Shock

Capital One Auto President Sanjiv Yajnik told CNBC that the share of income consumers devote to car payments has stayed roughly flat at around 10% since 2019. That figure held firm across every income bracket the lender examined. Monthly median payments have climbed sharply, jumping from $390 to $525 over the same period. Yet Yajnik argued those headline numbers obscure a more reassuring picture at the household level. The bank found that 80% of financed vehicle buyers remain below the widely accepted payment-to-income ceiling of 15%. Yajnik credited cautious consumer behavior, noting that transportation is not a discretionary expense and buyers treat it accordingly.

What Are ‘Forever Loans’ and Why Do Critics Worry

The term refers broadly to auto loan terms stretching six years or beyond. Lenders and analysts who flag these arrangements argue they leave buyers underwater, meaning they owe more on a vehicle than it is currently worth when they go to trade it in. Edmunds data show roughly 26% of used-vehicle trade-ins this year carried negative equity through April. The average shortfall hit $5,105, a 35% increase from 2019 levels. For new vehicles in the first quarter, over 90% of trade-ins with negative equity carried terms of at least 72 months, and nearly half stretched to 84 months.

Background: Pandemic Pricing Distorted the Baseline

The current strain traces back to pandemic-era chip shortages that throttled vehicle inventories while demand surged. That supply crunch drove used car values to historic highs, which paradoxically shielded many buyers from negative equity at the time. As values normalised and interest rates rose, buyers increasingly stretched loan terms to keep monthly payments manageable. Those longer timelines slow the pace at which owners build equity, leaving them exposed if they trade in before the loan matures.

Longer Loans, Longer Ownership Cycles

Yajnik acknowledged that extended loans require consumers to hold vehicles longer to extract their value. Prolonged ownership raises the risk of costly repairs or vehicles that need replacing before the loan is repaid. Still, he framed the arrangement as broadly rational. Consumers gain use of the vehicle and continue earning income throughout the loan’s life, he told CNBC. Critics inside the industry remain unconvinced, arguing the structure transfers meaningful financial risk onto buyers who may not fully grasp the trade-offs embedded in longer terms.

Read Next: Fed Holds Rates Steady as Tariff Uncertainty Clouds Outlook