Caribbean Hot Sauce Producers Face Shortages as Hurricane Damage Hits Scotch Bonnet Supply

BBC Business reported Saturday that Jamaica’s hot sauce manufacturers are warning of supply shortfalls and steep price increases, driven by a severe Scotch bonnet shortage rooted in consecutive hurricane seasons and worsening climate conditions.

A Condiment Under Pressure

Hot pepper sauce holds a place on Caribbean dining tables comparable to ketchup across North America. Jamaican brands have expanded well beyond the region, reaching shelves at Walmart, Tesco, and Woolworths. That global growth now faces a significant obstacle. A combination of extreme weather, crop disease, and pest damage has made the temperamental Scotch bonnet pepper increasingly difficult to source at viable prices.

Walkerswood executive Sean Garbutt told the BBC the company was forced to cancel orders following recent hurricane damage. The brand exports more than 95% of its output, shipping the equivalent of 500 cargo containers overseas last year alone. Its signature Scotch Bonnet Pepper Sauce relies entirely on fresh yellow peppers, with no artificial colouring added. That dependency makes supply unpredictable.

Hurricane Melissa Compounds Years of Losses

Last October, Hurricane Melissa struck Jamaica as the most powerful storm in the island’s recorded history. It arrived while the agricultural sector was still rebuilding from Hurricane Beryl the previous year. Some farmers responded by shifting to sweet potato, a hardier and more consistently profitable crop. That shift has further reduced the volume of Scotch bonnets available to sauce manufacturers.

Drew Gray, whose family has operated Gray’s Pepper for more than five decades, said Scotch bonnet prices surged roughly tenfold immediately after Melissa hit. Over the past two years, costs have risen by an estimated 40-50% in total. The company has adopted a strategy of holding up to six months of inventory ahead of hurricane season. Gray noted the approach strains working capital but keeps production running through disruptions.

Climate Risk Reshapes the Supply Chain

Beyond hurricanes, Scotch bonnets are highly sensitive to excess rainfall, which promotes fungal infections and can also dilute the peppers’ heat levels. Garbutt acknowledged that customers occasionally report milder-than-expected batches, a direct result of wet growing conditions. The broader climate trajectory for the Caribbean suggests these pressures are unlikely to ease. Gray said the region bears a disproportionate share of climate-related agricultural disruption globally.

Both producers expressed determination to maintain output despite the volatility. For an industry increasingly embedded in international retail supply chains, however, the structural fragility of a single key ingredient poses a lasting challenge to growth and price stability.

Read Next: Fed Holds Rates Steady as Inflation Data Remains Mixed