Retail’s Strong Q1 May Have Been Propped Up by Tax Refunds and BNPL

CNBC reported Monday that the US retail sector posted unusually strong first-quarter results, but analysts believe elevated tax refunds and a surge in buy now, pay later use helped paper over genuine cracks in household finances.

A Quarter That Defied the Gloom

Multiple economic headwinds gathered force between February and May. US military action in the Middle East pushed gasoline prices sharply higher, consumer confidence sank, and household budgets remained stretched by persistent inflation. Yet when major retailers released earnings over recent weeks, the numbers looked broadly healthy — profits grew, revenues rose, and corporate guidance held steady. Retail analyst Neil Saunders of GlobalData told CNBC the period was “surprisingly robust,” noting shoppers continued spending despite sentiment surveys flashing red.

Tax Refunds Did the Heavy Lifting

Analysts say two specific tailwinds deserve scrutiny. First, tax refunds this season arrived in larger amounts and to more households than in the prior year, giving cash-constrained consumers a temporary spending buffer. Second, buy now, pay later adoption accelerated, letting shoppers stretch budgets further than underlying incomes might otherwise permit.

Target offers one of the clearest illustrations. The retailer posted a 5.6% rise in comparable sales, its first positive comp in five quarters. Yet Target’s finance chief acknowledged directly that stronger-than-usual refunds helped drive those numbers, cautioning that the benefit would dissipate through the remainder of the year. Best Buy reported a 2% comparable-sales gain and similarly credited part of that improvement to the refund cycle — even as it appeared to lose market share in a broader electronics market that grew faster than the chain itself. At Burlington, management estimated refund-driven spending accounted for roughly 1.5 to 2 percentage points of a 6% comparable-sales gain.

Why Q2 Is the Cleaner Read

Retail analyst Janine Stichter of BTIG told CNBC that April and May already showed choppier trends as the refund effect faded. She cautioned that the consumer has not collapsed, but that Q2 results will strip away the distortions and reveal whether household spending is genuinely resilient or simply delayed in its slowdown. Guidance from Walmart, Ross Stores, and TJX Companies for the current quarter struck a notably more cautious tone, signaling that executives themselves expect the coming months to be harder.

With the refund tailwind gone and gas prices still elevated, the second quarter should deliver a far less forgiving verdict on the American consumer’s true financial health.

Read Next: Fed Holds Rates Steady as Inflation Stays Stubborn