Trump Administration Split Over Pope Leo XIV’s AI Warning
CNBC reported Tuesday that a public dispute over Pope Leo XIV’s artificial intelligence warning has cracked open a visible rift inside the Trump administration. The disagreement arrives as the White House doubles down on AI deregulation as a core second-term priority.
Burgum and Vance Take Opposite Sides
Interior Secretary Doug Burgum dismissed Pope Leo XIV’s concerns about AI in a Fox Business interview. He questioned whether weighing in on technology policy falls within a pope’s responsibilities. The remarks stood in direct contrast to those of Vice President JD Vance, the administration’s most prominent Catholic official. Vance called the papal message “profound” in a separate NBC interview. He framed it as exactly the kind of moral leadership the church should offer during the AI age. The contradiction between two senior officials drew immediate attention from outside observers. Duke Divinity School theology professor Peter Casarella suggested the administration overreached in earlier Vatican criticism and is now walking back its position.
What the Pope Actually Said
Pope Leo XIV released his first papal encyclical on May 25. The 42,300-word document called for stronger oversight of artificial intelligence and raised concerns about job displacement, growing inequality, and autonomous weapons systems operating beyond human control. The document was released alongside Christopher Olah, a co-founder of Anthropic. That detail added a further wrinkle, as Anthropic has previously clashed with the Trump administration over military access to its technology. University of Notre Dame law professor Paolo Carozza described the dialogue between the pope and technology leaders as historically unprecedented.
A Longer-Running Vatican Dispute
The AI clash is the newest front in a broader and escalating conflict between Washington and the Holy See. Since taking office, Pope Leo XIV has criticized the administration’s mass deportation policies and its military campaign in Iran. He also declined an invitation to join a Trump-organized peace initiative. President Trump has responded with personal attacks, calling Leo weak on crime and hostile to American foreign policy. Leo publicly stated he has no fear of the Trump administration.
Political Stakes Heading Into Midterms
The dispute carries real electoral weight. Trump won 55% of Catholic voters in the 2024 election. Analysts and Catholic advocacy groups warn that continued public conflict with a popular American-born pope could erode that support ahead of November midterms. Michael Toscano of the Institute for Family Studies said the administration’s resistance to reasonable AI guardrails will ultimately prove to be a political miscalculation. Trump also recently delayed an executive order that would have established a voluntary AI safety review process, reversing course after sustained pressure from technology industry lobbyists.
Read Next: Fed Signals Patience as Inflation Data Keeps Rate Cuts on Hold
