American Pilots Union Backs United CEO’s Merger Vision as Pressure on American Leadership Mounts

CNBC reported Tuesday that the president of American Airlines’ pilots union praised United Airlines CEO Scott Kirby‘s now-abandoned merger overture. The union chief called it a display of the kind of bold, forward-looking strategy his own carrier currently lacks.

Pilots Union Turns Rejected Bid Into a Leadership Critique

Allied Pilots Association President Nick Silva sent a message to members Monday that was seen by Reuters. Silva described Kirby’s vision as potentially transformative for passengers, communities, and American’s own workforce. He stopped short of formally endorsing any merger. Instead, Silva used Kirby’s approach as a lens to examine what he called the failure of American’s current leadership to articulate a compelling long-term strategy. He urged American’s senior management to give serious consideration to any strategic alternative rather than offer quick, defensive rejections.

Silva also disclosed that outside parties have approached the union about alternative plans for the airline’s future. American’s management had reportedly asked whether anyone was attempting to recruit APA pilots to support a rival proposal. Silva’s response, according to the email, was simply “Yes,” though he did not identify who was involved.

A Deepening Rivalry and a Blocked Deal

United first floated the merger concept during a late-February meeting between Kirby and President Trump, sources previously told Reuters. The discussion had originally been scheduled around the future of Washington Dulles Airport. Kirby argued the combined carrier could withstand antitrust review, but the proposal faced significant regulatory obstacles given the two airlines’ overlapping routes across major U.S. markets. Trump subsequently said he did not support the tie-up. United confirmed last month it had dropped the pursuit after American declined to engage.

Years of Underperformance Fuel Union Unrest

American has trailed both Delta Air Lines and United on profitability for years. That gap has gradually become a governance flashpoint. In February, APA formally urged American’s board to take decisive action and requested a direct meeting with its full membership. The airline’s flight attendants union separately issued a no-confidence vote against Chief Executive Robert Isom and called for new leadership. Public labor campaigns against sitting executives outside contract negotiations remain rare in the industry. Silva argued in his email that restoring American to genuine global prominence would require bold ideas and real leadership, neither of which he suggested the current C-suite had demonstrated.

American did not immediately respond to a request for comment on the pilots union statement.

Read Next: Delta and United Widen Profit Gap Over American as Labor Tensions Rise