Capital One Says Auto Loan Stress Is Overblown

CNBC reported Saturday that Capital One Auto President Sanjiv Yajnik is largely unconcerned about the surge in long-term vehicle financing. His argument centres on one metric: payment-to-income ratios have barely moved since 2019.

Monthly Payments Up, but the Ratio Holds

Median monthly car payments have climbed sharply over the past seven years. Capital One’s own data show the figure rising from $390 in 2019 to $525 today. That is a 35% jump in dollar terms.

Yet Yajnik told CNBC that the share of take-home pay consumers direct toward vehicle costs has stayed near 10% across every income bracket. Some 80% of borrowers who finance through Capital One sit below the widely accepted 15% payment-to-income threshold. Consumers are stretching loan terms to keep monthly costs manageable, he said, rather than overextending their budgets.

What Are ‘Forever Loans’?

The debate over so-called forever loans has grown louder as six- and seven-year auto loan terms become routine. Critics argue that extended terms leave buyers underwater the moment they try to trade in. When a vehicle’s market value drops faster than the loan balance, the owner carries negative equity into their next purchase.

Edmunds data show roughly 26% of used-vehicle trade-ins this year through April involved negative equity. The average shortfall was $5,105, up 35% from 2019. For new-vehicle trade-ins in the first quarter alone, the average negative equity figure reached $7,183. More than 90% of those new-vehicle loans with negative trade-ins carried terms of at least 72 months.

Background: Pandemic Pricing Left a Long Hangover

The roots of today’s tension trace back to 2020 and 2021. A global semiconductor shortage gutted vehicle production just as demand spiked. Inventory dried up, used-car prices soared, and buyers who purchased at peak values built up equity quickly. That cushion has since eroded. As prices corrected, trade-in values fell faster than loan balances, flipping many owners into negative territory.

Lender Confidence Versus Industry Caution

Yajnik acknowledged that longer loans slow the pace at which buyers accumulate equity. He argued, however, that consumers are making a rational trade-off: lower monthly costs in exchange for a longer payoff horizon. The vehicle still provides daily utility and supports the borrower’s ability to earn income, he said.

Not everyone in the sector shares that confidence. Edmunds head of insights Jessica Caldwell noted publicly that rising loan terms mean any early trade-in increasingly saddles buyers with residual debt they must roll into their next financing agreement. That cycle, she warned, compounds over time.

Read Next: Fed Holds Rates Steady as Tariff Uncertainty Clouds Outlook